Background image: A Marvelish Life Background image: A Marvelish Life
Social Icons

Such Lovely Skin by Tatiana Schlote-Bonne

2 min read

Table of Contents

Content Warnings: Death of a sibling, car accident, grief, guilt, self-harm ideation, blood/gore, gaslighting, cyberbullying, parental grief

Such Lovely Skin does something clever with the evil doppelgänger premise: the monster is more than a corruption of the original. It's like a photocopy set to maximum contrast so that all Viv's worst qualities are emphasized.

Viv is a Twitch streamer. She's also a chronic liar who is haunted by the shadow of her little sister's death. When a murderous mimic comes along and starts destroying everything she's building, it finds that process all too easy. After all, Viv has spent so long lying to get sympathy and scattering lies like salt that no one even believes her when she tries to plan the truth. She's not to blame for the horrors that unfold, but she is to blame for nobody believing her this time.

It's the girl who cried wolf turned up to eleven, and this time the wolf is wearing her face.

Tatiana Schlote-Bonne's debut novel is viciously smart about the mechanics of consequences. The horror is as much Viv's own slow-motion realisation that she's lying in the bed she made as much as it is the monster. Yeah, sure, the doppelganger is terrifying too, but it's also armed with ammunition of Viv's own making. It takes every lie, takes every one of her slick manipulations, and uses them as part of its arsenal. It's The Ring with receipts, and the total at the end is brutal.

I suppose that some readers will balk at Viv's voice—the internet slang and acronyms, the gamer lingo—but I've spent a long time on the internet, and it read as pretty authentic to me. Schlote-Bonne gets online culture. More importantly, she nails her depictions of the particular hellscape that is being a young woman trying to build a platform. From the casual misogyny to the way Viv's history of lying intersects with our culture's broader unwillingness to believe women, it's not subtle. It shouldn't be. It never is in real life, at least not for those of us up to our chins in it.

The grief the characters are dealing with is also handled with unflinching clarity, and I appreciated that. Viv isn't doing her grieving in the "acceptable" ways, but grief is messy. She's numb, she's selfish, and she's trying to throw money at her parents as penance as a replacement for the honest truth.

Meanwhile, her parents themselves are drowning in their own loss and can barely see Viv, which is its own kind of wound. I've lost a son, so I recognise that feeling of drowning, and Schlote-Bonne doesn't reach for the parents' hands to pull them out of the water. It's an honest choice. Grief is ugly. It's uncomfortable. Schlote-Bonne doesn't sanitise it, nor does she offer her characters an easy grace for the wreckage their grief leaves in its wake.

Some readers might call some of the twists predictable, but I say there's a difference between obvious and properly telegraphed. Yeah, the clues are there if you're paying attention. So what? I think that's a mark of good craft in a mystery; a plot twist you can't see coming at all often means the author cheated by not giving you enough clues. Schlote-Bonne plays fair with her structure.

Such Lovely Skin is fast-paced, genuinely creepy, and smarter than it needs to be. I'm still thinking about that final scene, wondering if maybe the doppelgänger might have been the honest one all along.

Author

Amanda Růžičková 66 Articles

Poet in Prague, Midwest-born, fluent in reinvention. Living with stage IV lung cancer and too many unread books. Writing with love and uncertainty—chasing meaning and the everyday beauty that survives

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Subscribe to our email newsletter and unlock access to members-only content and exclusive updates.

Comments